Give each provider the same business problem and ask what they would deliver, who would do the work, and what you could inspect. That lets you compare a monitoring subscription with a managed service without assuming they include the same work.
FoundUp publishes this guide and offers AI visibility monitoring and scoped website and content work. The criteria below are for comparing proposals, including ours.
Start with a brief every provider can answer
Pick a priority service, its current website page, the market and language you care about, and a few buyer questions. Explain what your team can approve and publish. Ask each provider to separate diagnosis, monitoring, recommended changes, writing and implementation in their proposal. A quote that covers the first two can be a fit if your team can act on the findings.
Ask to see the evidence behind a report
Ask for a redacted example covering the exact question, platform, date, market and language, the answer or permitted record, and any available source URL. Ask how the provider marks unavailable sources and failed runs. Find out whether it separates a brand mention from a recommendation and whether it checks accuracy. Ask what changes to the question list or platform would prevent a fair comparison with last month's report.
A screenshot can help you understand one result. A sample report should also show what was checked, what remains unknown and which action the provider recommends. Ask whether you can export the underlying records under the quoted scope.
Ask who changes the website
Give the provider a scenario. An AI answer repeatedly says you serve an area you do not cover. Ask which source they would verify, who confirms the business fact, and what their team would change if the official page is unclear. Then ask who drafts, approves, publishes and checks the revision. For an implementation proposal, ask how they record changes and handle a correction if approved wording turns out to be wrong.
Compare commercial terms on the same basis
Request an itemized statement of scope. Check setup and recurring charges, currency, billing period, included allowances, and what requires a separate quote. Ask who owns content, records and access, and how renewals or exit work. Have the provider state which platforms, markets and review frequency the quote covers. A broad platform list is less informative than clear coverage for your actual questions.
Avoid paying twice for overlapping SEO and GEO work
Ask both providers to itemize work by page and deliverable. If your SEO retainer already covers rewriting a service page, ask the GEO provider to separate answer sampling and recommendations from any proposed rewrite. Agree who records the observation, who drafts the edit, who approves and publishes it, and who checks the result. Give each change one implementation owner and use one shared change log.
Match those assignments to the quote. Remove duplicates, identify what counts as additional work, and agree who can authorize extra charges. Before signing, ask for a sample export and confirm which prompt sets, answer logs, source URLs and change records your team can keep, in what format and when. Record who transfers files and account access at exit so the next team can continue the work.
Compare two scopes against the work you can do
Illustrative buying scenario. A supplier wants to correct inconsistent descriptions of its service area. Its marketing team can approve changes but has no one available to edit the website. Provider A offers a report and recommendations. Provider B quotes monitoring, copy edits and publishing after approval. Ask both to identify the page they would check and what the team would receive when the issue is closed. Then compare the full cost of delivering the fix, including any internal or third-party publishing work.
If a quote includes publishing, ask who needs access, what approval is required, and how you can verify the live change. A useful acceptance test is whether an unfamiliar reader can identify the correct service area on the live page. Later AI observations can be reviewed separately. Apply the same ownership and acceptance questions to any ongoing content work.
Ten questions to send to every provider
1. Which buyer questions, markets, languages and platforms would you cover for this offer?
2. What can I inspect in a redacted sample, including the exact question, answer, sources and missing-data markers?
3. What is included in diagnosis, writing, website changes and publishing, and what would cost extra?
4. Who verifies facts, approves changes and has access to publish them?
5. How will you show which pages changed, what was checked and who accepted the work?
6. How do you distinguish mentions, citations, recommendations, accuracy and actual business results?
7. What baseline, review cadence and comparison rules will you use when the question list or platform changes?
8. What are the setup fee, recurring charges, allowances and approval process for extra work?
9. Who owns the content, site access, configuration and raw observation records, and what can we export?
10. What happens when we cancel or change providers, including notice, access removal, export and handover?
Compare the scopes fairly
| Scope | What to look for in the quote | When it can fit |
|---|---|---|
| Monitoring-only | Question setup, observation records, reporting and any recommendations. Ask what editing or publishing is included. | You already have people who can verify and implement changes. |
| Managed GEO | Observation plus clearly defined content or site work. Confirm approval responsibilities and whether publication is included. | Your team needs help turning findings into verified changes. |
| SEO agency | Search discovery, page improvements and reporting for organic search. Confirm whether AI answer observation is included or separately scoped. | Your main gap is organic discoverability or website content. An agency may offer broader work if the quote documents it. |
These are scope descriptions for comparing proposals. Ask providers to document the actual deliverables when a package crosses categories.
Score proposals using written evidence
Copy the table into a spreadsheet. Adjust weights before reviewing quotes. For each row assign 0 when the requirement is absent or evidence is missing, 1 when it is partially documented, and 2 when documented and acceptable. Calculate points as weight × score ÷ 2, then add the rows. If a critical requirement is missing, resolve it before using the total to decide.
| Dimension | Illustrative weight | Evidence to request | A | B |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Buyer-task coverage | 15 | Sample question list, markets and platform limits | 2 | 2 |
| Reporting and inspectability | 15 | Redacted observation and reporting schedule | 2 | 2 |
| Website execution | 20 | Named edit and publication owner with acceptance criteria | 0 | 2 |
| Approval and access | 15 | Approval steps and access responsibilities | 1 | 2 |
| Pricing and allowances | 15 | Comparable written total and extra-work terms | 2 | 1 |
| Ownership and export | 10 | Content rights, account access and export format | 2 | 2 |
| Exit terms | 10 | Notice period and documented handover | 1 | 1 |
| Weighted total | 100 | Sum of weighted points | 67.5 | 87.5 |
Illustrative evaluation. Apply the table to the supplier above. A supplies a clear report, export terms and quote, but no editing or publishing. B documents both implementation and approvals, but its quote leaves extra-work charges unclear. Both have incomplete handover terms. For A, the execution row contributes 20 × 0 ÷ 2 = 0. For B it contributes 20. The scores favor B for this supplier, but the purchase decision still depends on clarifying additional charges and exit terms. If the supplier hires a web editor, A can be evaluated again against the new division of work.
Review written scope before accepting a ranking or citation promise. Ask which work can be demonstrated as complete and which outcomes are observations. Require a clear owner for essential deliverables and compare fees only after both proposals describe the same responsibilities.
For FoundUp specifically, the public service description covers selected AI observations and agreed website or content changes. Customer approval precedes agreed publishing. Confirm applicable deliverables and terms for your project. Monitoring scope · Plans and pricing · Service FAQ